Reg,
Gandhi was once asked what he thought about Western Civilization. He replied that he thought that it might be a good idea if it happened.
Any civilization would have done Gandhi good. He was not the nice guy everybody thought he was. Think about Amanda Marshall’s “Birmingham” or Arthur Smith’s “Dueling Banjos” played on sitars. *Yeech!*
Also, his Satyagraha hogs all the limelight and overshadows the thousands of Indian soldiers and sailors who fought and died for Indian Independence, not to mention the millions of both Hindus and Muslims who were dislocated and murdered in the partition of India and Pakistan.
And if it wasn’t for the Ghandis and Nehru encouraging Indians to hand-spin cloth in the home, Indians could have done safer, less difficult, more profitable work, like maybe being the voice of customer service in the 1950s and 1960s or raising GMO self-harvesting saffron as cheap as table salt.
The Hitch could have had lots of choice cuts of jib if he had done a biography of Gandhi.