Reply To: Spiritual atheist.

@SimonPaynton I don’t think you have thought this “life after death” thing through completely. Let’s say I get hit by a car and it damages my brain, so I’m semi-vegetative. Do I get my old brain back? Let’s say I have epilepsy, or perhaps another mental disorder. Is that cured? Would I even be the same person if it was? How about a small child or baby that dies. Do they continue after as a perpetual child? Supposing I was born with a brain tumor and it was surgically removed successfully. Do I get the tumor back? When I die at 90 years old, do I come back as a decrepit nonagenarian? Or fit and healthy again? How about transgendered people who have elective surgery to change gender? Do they get reverted to their original gender again? There are so many more examples I could give, but I think that’s enough to start with.

Simon, simply saying “I don’t know” isn’t going to be good enough to support your theory.