Activity
-
jakelafort posted an update 8 years, 4 months ago
Sorry Mr. Bean, but i have some hang-up about joining groups. Rough enough to be a member on this site.
Yes, i think self-awareness is on a scale or spectrum. In humans a person in a coma, minimally conscious state or in latter stages of alzheimers on one end and a meditating yogi Prabhupada Baktivedanti his divine grace on other. Regular and irregular Joes and Janets in between.
And so it is for other animals both within the species and as a species. You may not like to discuss other animals but if we are subscribing to natural world then free will must be understood in terms of evolution. We would not ascribe free will to amoeba so where does it creep in? Otherwise we posit a form of special creation (or perhaps we rationalize by elevating the cerebral cortex)
Defining free will? I keep it simple. An individual can only have free will if in full control of faculties, thoughts and behavior. Such an individual can do as she will and will as she will.
As for AI, shit i don’t know. I am relying on intuition and the opinion of various experts i have heard or read. It seems to me human conceit to assume consciousness and awareness is exclusively the domain of the biological critters. And seeing how far and fast AI has progressed makes sense to me it will be aware and the extrapolation of the experts in seeing the genesis of super intelligence is idk…a good wager?
You said: “Sorry Mr. Bean, but i have some hang-up about joining groups. Rough enough to be a member on this site.”
I say: I accidentally just found this update you posted, because it’s not in the “usual” kind of place to maintain a thread, unless one checks every member’s page of of their personal updates. Are you saying a group is “rough” because it requires a different way to navigate threads? Communicating this way, solely via your personal page is cumbersome and easily missed by other members.
I also feel I must split a response into several different posts, here at the /members/jakelafort page, because other nicities like formatting text and paragraphs for readability are features not provided.
… and this page lacks an editing feature, so I can’t fix the myriad of typos and poor writer syndrome I’m afflicted with. Anyway…
You said: “You may not like to discuss other animals […]”
I say: That was just a suggestion wrt that single “Starters” post, for the sake of simplicity because I think it’s much easier to *start* sharing human consciousness experiences between humans. I do believe animals have some consciousness we can speak to, like laughing, even. But I started at the baby steps level of laughing, so to speak. Yes, e.g. Chimps laugh, too.
You said: “or perhaps we rationalize by elevating the cerebral cortex”
I say: True, which is absolutely relevant when compared to amoebas (sp?), but only relatively relevant wrt other animals that also have cerebral cortices, only smaller.
You said: ” An individual can only have free will if in full control of faculties, thoughts and behavior. Such an individual can do as she will and will as she will.”
I say: I understand that, but think it oversimplifies a potentially deep aspect of free will, e.g. what about people who are mentally disabled, especially those that have lost some kind of mental faculty and are now unable to think as well as they used to. Or more commonly, how about our own debilitating, drug induced stupors? Do we still have as much free will capability, when our cerebral, advanced mental faculties are damaged?
And I forgot or neglected to mention, what do you mean by “full control of faculties”? I don’t know about you, but I cannot even know when I’m in full control from day to day, much less *ever*. That strongly hints to me the sliding scale of capability, which in the bigger picture even hints to me a difference in capability (and therefor access to full free will) depending on which person’s free will we’re investigating.
You said: “It seems to me human conceit to assume consciousness and awareness is exclusively the domain of the biological critters. And seeing how far and fast AI has progressed makes sense to me it will be aware and the extrapolation of the experts in seeing the genesis of super intelligence is idk…a good wager?”
I say: OK, but the advancement of AI still depends on humans designing it. Sure, that will change, when AI “takes over” the design. But when they have more power than us, would you say it’s ok for THEM to define what (e.g.) our existence is worth in the cosmos? Could they feel they have the right to encroach on our existence, till death? How about going back to pre-AI days… would a normal human being back in those days feel it’s arrogant to not invent AI that could destroy humanity? The difference now is there are a whole lot of geeks getting excited over their creations, and happily give their creation carte blanch, to the detriment of humanity en toto.
link test: https://atheistzone.com/members/jakelafort/activity/13298/
Somehow you have organized this parley!