Kuba Adamów
-
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoIt’s pretty boring to be more into defending -isms than doing real philosophy.
I’m not defending anything Simon, I’m calling out your ignorant claim that “the two could be mixed” or whatever. These systems were established generations before we were born. I am not in charge of them nor would me hoping they would change have any effect. Own up to y…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoDavis wrote:
Until you educate yourself on this, discussion over.It’s pretty boring to be more into defending -isms than doing real philosophy.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoReg the Fronkey Farmer wrote:
You could end up with the best of all possible worlds with that optimistic ideal.All other things being equal, higher quality cooperation would be expected to lead to higher quality results.
-
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoIt’s not up for debate, that your theories might have something wrong about them?
What deontological ethics are and what utilitarian ethics are…are not my own personal theories. They are well established and their approaches to moral problems cannot be combined any more than oil and water can. If you weren’t so monumentally intellectually lazy a…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months ago@davis – so you can’t answer my question? It’s not up for debate, that your theories might have something wrong about them?
I would have thought it is much more interesting to think about how intentions, actions and consequences are connected, than to keep insisting that they are not, for no good reason, other than the inadequacy of the…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoDon’t you want your theories to be correct? Or do you just want to maintain your special theories, right or wrong?
Simon, educate yourself a little. I am not arguing with someone that the sky is not blue but green. Pick up some books and read.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoDavis wrote:
1. Unambiguously the case, yes the two are exclusive…to say otherwise is to argue that something that is boiling is actually frozen.Don’t you want your theories to be correct? Or do you just want to maintain your special theories, right or wrong?
-
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoThe problem is that people (apparently, for some reason) insist on the two being separate and exclusive. If intentions, attitudes etc. lead to actions, and actions lead to consequences – they’re not separate, but connected by a thread of prosocial or antisocial intention.
Simon, I am not arguing with you something that is:
1. Unambiguously the…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoDavis wrote:
Utilitarianism and deontological ethics cannot be bridged or merged or compromised. They are two totally different systems. Taking away the absolutism of deontological ethics would make it an entirely new system, as with taking away the flexibility of utilitarianism. It would not be utilitarianism anymore, but something new. It is… -
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoTo go back to the original post: the introduction of a negative causal factor, allowing staff to refuse vaccines, in order to stop them leaving the workforce, could lead to a sub-optimal outcome and may need remedial action in the future if unvaccinated staff spread covid to vulnerable patients. So, it’s a flaw in the outcome, not to say a p…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 10 months agoOnce you allow the government to impose speed limits, it is a slippery slope to the government eventually implanting chips in every citizen’s brain. Speed limits are anti-freedom, anti-American and probably break several constitutional amendments. No speed limits means more freedom which means more prosperity which means true liberty and what the…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 10 months agoSurely there’s a problem if they are claimed to be mutually exclusive, when in fact, they must be complementary.
-
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 10 months agoNo. I entirely disagree that neither consequences nor intentions are the ultimate explaining power in ethics. Different systems deal with them differently and if you claim one is the all-explainer, then you are simply favouring one moral system over another rather than describing the variety of moral systems in philosophy.
Virtue ethics would not…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 10 months agoReg the Fronkey Farmer wrote:
This woman died recently from Covid after intentionally contracting the virus.That’s a truely bizarre story.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 10 months ago@unseen – it’s entirely up for debate, since the term is not well defined and still poorly understood. There are many different current definitions.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 10 months agoAlso, the way we behave towards ourselves can be seen as moral or immoral – as far as it affects others. For example, a drug addict lets the side down because they create a mess for others to deal with.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 10 months agoIt’s in the moral domain if it’s social (in my opinion). If you spill a drink on someone else’s carpet, but it’s unintentional – you can’t be blamed for an honest mistake. But your lack of intention is still in the moral domain, because it’s social.
You’re right, intentions are an important part of morality, that we judge people on. We bl…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 10 months agoUnseen wrote:
Morality is all about intentionality.I don’t know. Morality is a vast and sprawling domain of interest. But I see your point maybe: intentions and actions are what we have control over.
You can interact honestly, deceptively, or sinisterly.
Those social activities I mentioned all involve moral principles (of conversational e…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 10 months agoThose are all morally neutral activities apart from intention
Are they?
-
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 10 months agoYou could see it like that, in a wider sense. I was talking about interacting with people personally, or interacting with one’s group.
Uh huh.
- Load More