Kuba Adamów
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoReg the Fronkey Farmer wrote:
Can you have compassion for “law breakers” without some degree of judgement?Prisoners have human rights – if not autonomy and liberty, then at least, fairness as respect: the maximum benefit and minimum harm available to them. The practice may fall woefully short, but prisoners are in theory entitled to medi…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoDavis wrote:
and it is hard to imagine how they can considering we have evolved to be viciously violent, rapey, racist, controlling, indifferent and frequently very cruel on a mass scaleOn an individual level, evolutionary ethics has answers for the questions of why these exist.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoAutumn wrote:
Fairness is also difficult to define in abstraction. The very concept of it isn’t that difficult to define, but what it actually means or what its particular value is is easier to define.I would define it as a distribution of benefit and harm on some kind of equal basis. This can be material or social benefit and harm. There are…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoReg the Fronkey Farmer wrote:
I suppose if it stops your “ordinary people” from committing crimes because they have no developed sense of morality, then it is better than nothing.I think the full range of moral repertoire is there for religious people to use, depending on their personality. Some people favour punishment and judgment; some peop…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agojakelafort wrote:
promotes good behavior? Punishes bad?I think this is true, but the question then becomes, what is good and bad behaviour? In some societies, it seems that compassion and human rights are not the most important values.
According to John Teehan, in “Religion and Morality: The Evolution of the Cognitive Nexus”, religion arose…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agojakelafort wrote:
Isn’t that eu word similar to another term used in philosophy that relates to happiness?Yes, eudaimonia, it means “long term pleasure” or “happiness” or something similar. As opposed to hedemonia, which means fleeting pleasure.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoReg the Fronkey Farmer wrote:
would you say that his ideas on eudaimonism – in that a moral action has its value measured by its capacity to produce happiness, was a stinker?I don’t know much about Nietzsche, but if he said that, that’s a good thing to say.
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoWe know that religious moral system work well by looking at the evidence.
Indeed. Since secularism is a relatively “new” thing, and all moral systems have been heavily influence by religion since civilisation began some millenia ago…I fail to see how “work well” makes sense when it was the only system around. Obviously it didn’t work that we…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoMy bibliography runs to 15 pages
That’s a whole lot of books you have read, none of which have sufficient material to cover even the basics. Very curious indeed.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoAutumn wrote:
Humans rationalize fairness where it doesn’t exist quite readily. While we tend to value the idea of fairness, we often do very little to ensure it exists in practice.Then we’re rationalising something, making it seem OK, when we can’t do much about it.
What happens more likely is that someone sells us an idea of fairness which d…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoReg the Fronkey Farmer wrote:
Which moral system is the worst in your opinion? Can we assume that Divine Command Theory (or Divine Comedy Theory as I have sometimes called it), is not worth the discussion time here.Actually, in theory, the religious moral system works well in its own way. It promotes good behaviour and punishes bad…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months ago@davis, I respect anyone who knows how to turn out good ideas.
Davis wrote:
pick up some books and read themMy bibliography runs to 15 pages.
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoSimon you are using the pronoun “we” as though you are a philosopher, a scholar or have sufficient knowledge of moral thought to make an impact or a difference. Sorry, but lacking rudimentary knowledge of basic concepts will automatically exclude you. The lack of a degree in a related field might also be a slight problem. This is why I am highly…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoAutumn wrote:
I don’t understand what you mean by ‘work’.They’re theories about the world that are wrong. A theory should be able to describe the world accurately and be used to make further predictions and generate more knowledge. None of these is possible with a wrong theory.
Autumn wrote:
I am not sure what you expect them to do, or what… -
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoDavis wrote:
which school of evolutionary ethics? It is not remotely an established field. If there are so many unresolved issues…how could it be a system people could rely on for everyday life?It’s not very well established as an ethical theory, in the sense that it’s me who’s extended it to become a meta-ethical theory, and I’m trying to get i…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoAutumn wrote:
I don’t understand the value of needing a comprehensive moral system for ordinary people to live by. I take it ‘ordinary people’ means people who are not moral philosophers.That’s a good point. What needs to be taught, is how to do what people do anyway, well. In studying evolutionary ethics, I’ve learned all kinds of things…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoI don’t understand the value of needing a comprehensive moral system for ordinary people to live by
Indeed
The basic tenets of a number of philosophical systems can be taught at a high school level.
Some even in elementary school. Shame they are not.
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoMy point is that there is no “comprehensive moral system”, supplied by Western moral philosophy, that is sound enough for ordinary people to use to live by
And you’ve concluded that after familiarising yourself beyond skimming a Wikipedia article with none of them?
In evolutionary ethics, there are no contradictions, only some unresolved are…
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoDavis wrote:
That doesn’t mean you must adhere to a comprehensive moral system,My point is that there is no “comprehensive moral system”, supplied by Western moral philosophy, that is sound enough for ordinary people to use to live by.
In evolutionary ethics, there are no contradictions, only some unresolved areas. It tells you what is good an…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoAre you saying they’re incompatible with each other?
How could a moral judgement have substance outside of a moral system? Most of us live and breathe modern western morality whether we know it or not. Western modern morality is heavily influenced by the likes of Kant, Hume, Locke, Sartre, Popper and others. That doesn’t mean you must adhere to a…[Read more]
- Load More