Diane

  • You would have to go far and wide simply soliciting passersby to find somebody to shock to death a stranger. Yes context matters. The point is that it is the appearance of AUTHORITY that causes the rank and file to do as they’re told, to go with the flow. That is fairly universal among us and throughout history. I agree it is not inherently good…[Read more]

  • Simon that just avoids the issue-begs the question.

    Accountable to others for what? Presumably that is a position held by the majority and imposed through authority/custom and in no way speaks to right or wrong. My point is right and wrong can not be dependent on the contemporary mores. That simply renders right and wrong meaningless andn fact…[Read more]

  • Simon, feeling moral means obeying an authority figure?

    Maybe so. Feelings are just feelings. Does it mean being moral. Social norms which fluctuate over the ages are tantamount to morality. If so morality is meaningless in terms of what is right and wrong.

    Hypothetical. Lets conduct an experiment.

    KNOCK SOME SENSE INTO THEM!

    LADIES AND…[Read more]

  • I have wondered whether fetus Glen raised in a religious household/culture would have become religious Glen. Of course i answer that question in the negative. I may be a bit biased.

    One can ask oneself same question in re Milgram. I can’t see myself complying. I have a history of questioning authority and no reason to believe i would have been…[Read more]

  • Simon, the conclusion is crap: In sum, though subjects in the Milgram paradigm violated their own reflective moral convictions, this may be because their conscience motives were hostage to the powerful moral appearances generated by the demands of the experimenter.

    Characterizing obedience in inflicting shocks is anything but moral. By the same…[Read more]

  • One of the potential explanations for the behaviour is that it was very easy for participants to pass off moral responsibility.

    Yes it is. That is a big part of submission to authority-we don’t need to or are not permitted to question those in authority whether their doings are benevolent or evil. I stand by what i said. Those subjects were led…[Read more]

  • Being easily led is a generalization and as with all/nearly all blanket there is nuance and there are exceptions.

    For instance once the die is cast it is not easy at all to lead. Those who have been already manipulated/indoctrinated can be incredibly unbending. Social media, political and religious ideology all do a number on humans so that once…[Read more]

  • I suppose it depends on how you define easily led. As a practical matter en masse we are easily led.

    Individually we know of the Millgram experiment (not sure i got name correct) and that experiment demonstrates conclusively/persuasively how the masses submit to authority even when it is against their nature or inclinations. Twain has a…[Read more]

  • Somebody once wrote the following: and while the Putins amongst us are potentially a special breed of fucked up, how do we account for the fact that people like him will move millions to kill over nothing on a semi-frequent basis?

    Here is what i make of it. We as a species are mindless and easily led. Out out brief candle of civilization. Our…[Read more]

  • I just witnessed a freaky thing. Went to the river to get in a quick workout up and down a steep hill. There was a baptism in progress. They were hooting and hollering-going wild! Is that normal for a baptism? I would have guessed it is like a tennis match…quiet please…thank you…ya know a perceived solemn occasion.

  • Here is what i get clicking on Sunday School September 11th 2022.

    Page Not Found
    Oops, it looks like this page does not exist.
    If you are lost use the search form below or visit our homepage

    Even after channelling Strega’s thanks the thanks were given. I understand though it is like a salmon going upstream-an irresistible urge.

    Reg writes…She…[Read more]

    • Apparently Kurt Cobain used to sign his autograph with “I have been in the presence of ” – insert name
        • I was not aware. That is pretty cool.

          It is so primal to be wowed and in awe of charismatic politicians, athletes, and performers. It is in our biology. I wonder if the psychology of sex for those in high esteem has been studied or more properly of the groupies.

          I have never and never will go weak in the knees at the presence or…

          [Read more]

    • Actually Reg, I couldn’t find this instalment of Sunday School until Robert posted his comment.

      Sunday School Sept 11th did not appear on the Sunday School forum page at all.

      I guess I’d never realised how much else the Queen was responsible for until now. 😉

    • Thanks, Reg!!

       

    • Good deed is twofold.

      Am announcing my intention to be excused from 10 holy Virgin Mare recitals about the progeny of the immaculate conception that cover 6 furlongs in one ten clear and how pace makes the race ya handicapping disgrace.

      First i am channeling Strega in thanking Reg.

      Next i am alerting Reg that page does not exist in new sunday…[Read more]

    • I am partial to the Virgin Mare and the Holy Horse Hoof.

      I am sure i will win every photo finish and have every inquiry decided righteously in accordance with my best interests as i genuflect and dissect the equine god with the horsey bod. In my trance of horse romance i take a chance on a steed from France trying dirt for the first time.…[Read more]

    • Unseen i assume you are suggesting violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act.

      I agree with Autumn that agreeing to kill or reduce advertising is not illegal.

    • I surmise with my fries that a scientific bent is how it went when observing torture in its excruciating desserts for the heretic. In that way science won the day. The Malleus Maleficarum makes the victim squirm before the delights of the harem. And man that shit would scare em.

      In every other one needn’t discover the strident lover-the…[Read more]

    • @Simon. Gods unconditional love (with the torture chamber in the basement but we won’t mention that)???

      The rain it falleth on the just, and on the unjust fella
      But chiefly on the just, because the unjust stole the just’s umbrella.

       

       

    • Thanks, Reg 🙂

    • Unseen, I am referring to the expertise of the physician. When one’s life is on the line that is the bottom line. I know there are sites that review physicians. It ain’t like ordering a pizza or sushi at a new joint on the prospect that the many glowing reviews are legit. It can be life and death and recovery.

      I don’t know much about medical…[Read more]

    • Load More