Kuba Adamów
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic They're not burning books yet, but… in the forum Politics 4 years, 9 months ago
Unseen wrote:
Are there books that need to be banned? Why or why not? Or is that a slippery slope, as they say?I think the Marquis de Sade’s books are really horrible. But they’re not banned. I don’t think you can ban books. Yes, it’s a slippery slope.
-
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agomorality is fiendishly intricate and interesting. That’s why so many people spend their time puzzling over it.
And that is the absolute perfectly evasive Chopra like response. Unseen is right…at some point, time to give it a rest. Should have days ago. And………scene.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months ago@unseen – morality is fiendishly intricate and interesting. That’s why so many people spend their time puzzling over it.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoThey’re all good points. Can you refute them?
-
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoYes Simon, clearly I am just stubborn in my old ways. I am just afraid of your revolutionary, internally consistent, clear and intelligible system that will smash the same ole shit and harbour in a completely new way of doing things. I am simply just afraid of such Earth shattering ideas such as:
- Morality isn’t one thing and can’t be sliced up…
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoDavis wrote:
Jesus bloody donkey crackers. What happened to you Simon? Where did you go wrong?Apparently, studying philosophy, and philosophers, makes people dogmatic and closed-minded towards doing new philosophy. People are allowed to do new philosophy. It’s interesting.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoReg the Fronkey Farmer wrote:
people do act in selfish ways … the Problem of EvilEvil or moral badness is defined as people acting selfishly at the needless expense of others. If they needed to be selfish, it wouldn’t be seen as bad.
We could say that evil is the worst of this: when someone deliberately hurts others for the enjoyment of it.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoReg the Fronkey Farmer wrote:
The word “needlessly” is not necessary because people do act in selfish ways. By that I mean they act to achieve their own interests first. They do not act to “ideal standards” to achieve “optimum outcomes”.There’s nothing wrong in putting one’s own interests first. In fact, evolutionary ethics is based on inc…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoIn the case of morality, the job in hand is to collaborate to thrive and survive together
Yikes.
-
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months ago@davis – so the answer is “just because”. I’ve identified a weakness that you yourself have agreed with. I’m sure a moral philosophy professor would not be so dogmatic.
Jesus bloody donkey crackers. What happened to you Simon? Where did you go wrong?
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months ago@davis – so the answer is “just because”. I’ve identified a weakness that you yourself have agreed with. I’m sure a moral philosophy professor would not be so dogmatic.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoReg the Fronkey Farmer wrote:
In the mundane routine of everyday life most people carry out tasks to serve their own personal interest or the interests of people they share their lives with. Those people in turn reciprocate with acts of their own. I admit at times their actions may reach some zenith of excellence but never when they realise it is… -
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoSimon…do you want me to write to every philosopher, political scientist, dictionary, encyclopedia, intellectual and publishing house and try to get them to change the definition and character of “utilitariansim” and “deontological moral systems”? Because if you do…you will have to give me a good reason to other than the fact that some guy, who…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months ago@davis – explain why it’s not silly, pointless and dogmatic: “just because”. Give some actual reasons based on real life or facts of some kind.
In my opinion, this is an example of where conventional moral philosophy is unhinged from everyday life. If the study of morality is a science of everyday life – something’s wrong if someone can’t g…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoIf it is insisted that two complementary systems are mutually exclusive – this is just silly and pointless dogmatism.
And there I thought you were actually capable of conceding anything. My terrible mistake.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoDavis wrote:
There are advantages and disadvantages to all moral systems. None of them are inherently correct. None of them possibly could be as morality isn’t written into the fabric of the universe.By “correct”, I mean “factually accurate”. If it is insisted that two complementary systems are mutually exclusive – this is just silly and po…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoReg the Fronkey Farmer wrote:
What are “ideal standards” and who sets them and on what authority?Ideal standards are virtuous performance of one’s work in carrying out the task. For example, in fixing a car, in best practice one would do everything necessary to make sure it is done properly: don’t lose any pieces, make sure everything is tigh…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoIf there were two sets of circumstances, with everything the same, and something needed fixing
I guess this is as close as you are capable to conceding something. There are advantages and disadvantages to all moral systems. None of them are inherently correct. None of them possibly could be as morality isn’t written into the fabric of the…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoIf there were two sets of circumstances, with everything the same, and something needed fixing – if one person did their job well (living up to ideal standards) then the results are very likely to be better than if the other person did their job poorly (not living up to ideal standards).
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 9 months agoIf the two aren’t mixed, then there’s something wrong with them, because in actual real life, the phenomena they seek to describe, are mixed.
I’d rather study real life than -isms. This is precisely my point: moral philosophy is mired in ignorance of its own making.
- Load More