Kuba Adamów
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
PopeBeanie wrote:
Which leads me to believe there once was a survival benefit.I don’t think it’s about a survival benefit, although that may come as a by-product. I think it’s about enhancing and celebrating being alive.
-
D replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
Pope…that is fine. Could you then define these two kinds of spiritual then please?
-
D replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
@davis – whatever definitions I could give, are never going to encompass all the things that people mean by the word.
Simon, unless you are dealing wit poetry…why would you use a term that is this elusive? How can you achieve much (if anything) if people are talking about something different (or at least vaguely overlapping) when you can use so…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
@davis – whatever definitions I could give, are never going to encompass all the things that people mean by the word.
-
D replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
So…you want to use “spiritual” without defining it?
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
It’s not a definition, it’s just some examples of things that are called “spiritual”. Working in coordination with others towards a common goal can, in some circumstances, be a spiritual experience for people.
-
D replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
So then your definition is deficient and needs some refining.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
@davis – I doubt it. Other attributes of their experience would come to the fore, in a sporting team. On the other hand, if they were getting stoned, or otherwise thoughtful, on some occasions, they might think of it a bit that way. Perhaps it depends on how much into their volleyball they were.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
So, when people refer to spiritualism, they mean nothing? Spirituality, I should say.
-
D replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
To be clear here Simon, you are claiming that most people playing in a volleyball league would call their membership “spiritual”?
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
What’s the word? Eejit. This contradiction suggests that the guy is not talking about anything consistent or real.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
Unseen wrote:
I don’t think it’s what almost everybody who uses the term “spiritual” means by it.What do almost everybody else mean by the term?
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
He’s probably meditating using a timer, so it’s not a contradiction to say he lost track of time, entered a flow state, for ten minutes.
You could say I’m calling bogusness, based on my own subjective definition. However, I don’t think that is too far away from what most people mean. The term is used in the army. In the army they are co…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
Reg the Fronkey Farmer wrote:
“But Reg I am able to meditate and lose all sense of time. That is a spiritual event for me”. “How long do these experiences normally last for you”? “Oh, usually about 10 minutes of so. Sometimes only 5. But the important thing is that time become meaningless and that makes the experience all the more spiritual… -
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
Davis wrote:
I think most of them would disagree that what they are doing is spiritual, even though what they do could improve their well being, their mental state, (with knitting inner peace), better their lives or even [I cannot believe I am saying this] flourish. Would they be wrong?I disagree that most of them would disagree that it’s…[Read more]
-
D replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
I’m talking about being an active functioning member of an interdependent cooperative group or team of some kind, whose members are all working towards the same goal. If my goals are identified with those of my group, then it makes me feel better in all kinds of ways.
How is that different than a volleyball team, a knitting group making a big bl…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
Unseen wrote:
If “it (spirituality) means things like achieving and maintaining inner peace and happiness; and self-actualising: achieving personal potentials,” I don’t see how any of those things follow from feeling one is just a small part of an unimaginably large something bigger.They don’t follow from it, they’re just part of the portm…[Read more]
-
D replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
I am with Unseen on this Simon. I know you have been struggling for some time to come up with a meaningful definition of spiritual in a secular sense (as have many people including Sam Harris). I am yet to really hear a coherent definition that makes it worth holding onto all the baggage of spiritual when alternatives are far better (even the…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School April 10th 2022. in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 7 months agoYeah Autumn, in fact I had come back to completely change my text to the following:
The best way to inoculate yourself from people tired of the barriers they face communicating this and fighting for change: is to cover your eyes…pretend these problems are trivial or virtually solved and demean and belittle their struggle: exactly what Enco is…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Is spirituality minus the spirit still spiritual? in the forum Atheism 4 years, 7 months ago
I think spirituality is about maximising personal well being in a cooperative way. The reason for the cooperative part is that one of its meanings is to be part of something greater than oneself.
So, it means things like achieving and maintaining inner peace and happiness; and self-actualising: achieving personal potentials.
President Putin…[Read more]
- Load More