Kuba Adamów
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School 2nd January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoOf course it is a cop-out. Mass human cruelty is an evolutionary by-product. Nazi Germany is just an excessive example of what was going on for millennia anyways. Once humans started having a surplus of anything, they built unjust and unspeakably cruel systems. More altruistic and caring societies are exceptions that define the rule. Western…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School 2nd January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoI don’t have one. That would be more of a sociological and historical issue.
I can say that the in-group bias was strongly in play, against an imaginarily-harmful out-group, the Jews. When individuals become Nazis, outside of Nazi Germany, that’s often an issue of personality disorders, specifically narcissism. Hitler was probably a narcissist.
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School 2nd January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoAll I can do at this point is roll my eyes and sigh and laugh. Good luck with that Simon…I guess.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School 2nd January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoDavis – look, I’m studying evolutionary ethics, and you can’t stop me:

-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School 2nd January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoSimon, if you were a mathematician dealing with a completely new, contentious theory with little published work, dissenting voices and nothing approaching consensus (let’s call it Theory X), then yeah, it would be ridiculous to say “theory x says…” anything. The best you could get away with is: “some people believe that theory x says…” or “in…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School 2nd January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoDavis wrote:
If it is your own opinion just say so. If it is that of a particular author or even two just say so.Yes, but if you are a mathematician, say, or an engineer, do you have to name the author of every single idea you use to synthesise new ideas? Or do you just do mathematics or engineering to come up with answers to new questions?
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School 2nd January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoEvolutionary ethics places truth-telling…
Ugh. Did you not read me calling you out on making broad claims about evolutionary ethics? It is a new branch with a very diverse set of views and nothing remotely approaching consensus, not to mention most of it just describes the evolution of human morality without even developing a moral system.…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School 2nd January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoB doesn’t look like the best possible outcome to me, unless you mean the least worst.
Davis wrote:
The most common moral systems all deal with this quite differently and how they deal with it is telling of the general principles of that moral system and is extremely interesting.Evolutionary ethics places truth-telling within a cooperative…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School 2nd January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoNone of those possibilities is “to make the best possible outcome”; i.e., “I do something I feel to be wrong in order to make the best possible outcome”.
Did you not read B?
In evolutionary ethics, truth telling is helpful and even necessary within a cooperative context. The general guiding rule would seem to be, tell the truth when it is helpf…
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School 2nd January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoDavis wrote:
F) One or more of the aboveNone of those possibilities is “to make the best possible outcome”; i.e., “I do something I feel to be wrong in order to make the best possible outcome”. That’s my point: that right intentions and right actions bring about the optimum outcome, because intentions and actions are putting the conditions in…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School 2nd January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoWe do things we hold to be generally wrong in order to:
A) Ensure our self interests
B) Do something we believe is less harmful than the consequences
C) Believe it is a worthy exception
D) Cause we just feel like it and don’t have to explain ourselves to no one
E) Tell ourselves the rule doesn’t apply in that case
Though more usually:
F)…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School 2nd January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoWe do things we hold to be generally wrong in order to:
A) Ensure our self interests
B) Do something we believe is less harmful than the consequences
C) Believe it is a worthy exception
D) Cause we just feel like it and don’t have to explain ourselves to no one
E) Tell ourselves the rule doesn’t apply in that case
Though more usually:
F)…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School 2nd January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoBut do we break our moral rules for the sake of ultimately doing good, or to be selfish?
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School 2nd January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoI don’t buy the idea that consequentialism – judging an action on its consequences, and deontology – judging an action morally, in its own right, “often do, come into conflict”. Not all the time or every day for everyone.
Nope. We break our moral rules all the time. We judge others for doing things we “justify as okay” all the time. Good self-…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School 2nd January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoReg the Fronkey Farmer wrote:
our sense of right and wrong is interwoven with our personality.This is a very interesting article, which ties in personality traits with moral traits. I think I score highly on agreeableness, conscientiousness and openness to experience. Maybe everyone thinks that about themselves. Maybe it’s why I’m a po…[Read more]
-
D replied to the topic IS CHRISTMAS AND OTHER THINGS FROM EMPEROR CONSTANTINE BIBLICAL? in the forum Theism 4 years, 10 months ago
Groan. Michal, just don’t look up.
-
D replied to the topic What are shape shifting UFOs? in the forum Science 4 years, 10 months ago
Indeed. I am yet to read any ancient text that consistently made clear undeniable confirmable notable precise future predictions, revealed currently unknown knowledge (about human psychology, how the world works etc) or provided a system where followed led to reliable human happiness for all who followed. You may find 1-5% of the predictions work…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoUnseen wrote:
John RawlsAs I understand it, Rawls’ formulation of fairness was a distribution that all concerned could be happy with.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoFor happiness I prefer the definition “a state of satisfaction with one’s life”.
Pleasure is at the heart of my theories about evolutionary ethics. The hypothesis is that fitness benefits are rewarded with pleasure, and the loss or lack of them produces pain. Now, humans can achieve their fitness cooperatively: in concert with others. It is do…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School December 26th 2021 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoEudaimonia and hedonia:
it’s an interesting question, what constitutes human flourishing. It has to be long term in my opinion, although short term pleasure is necessary for long term flourishing. Probably, repeated short term pleasure, and the prospect of more.
Here’s an article which highlights how short term pleasure is felt by the body a…[Read more]
- Load More