frb
-
Reg the Fronkey Farmer started the topic Sunday School 8th December 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months agoWhen you mix religion and politics, you get politics.
Religion in public schools is being tested by Christian conservatives but thanks to Christians, kids in Ohio can take classes in Satanism during school hours.
A culture of censorship is creeping across British society.
Atheist legal group urges appeals court to uphold ban on Minnesota prison…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months agoPopeBeanie wrote:
For believers in free will, I ask, do you believe you have power over determinism, or is determinism not even a thing?It depends on how binding the restrictions are.
-
PopeBeanie replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months agoSo I’m devil’s advocate for both sides, now.
For believers in free will, I ask, do you believe you have power over determinism, or is determinism not even a thing?
For those arguing against free will, is there any harm in others believing in it?
I’m not on the fence. I don’t believe it exists in an absolute sense, but I’m happy to ride as if it…[Read more]
-
PopeBeanie replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months agojakelafort wrote:
Somebody asks you do you believe? Have the integrity to say yes or no. And if asked for an explanation don’t go all cock and bull jive turkey circumlocution and obfuscation.Seems to me that all JP was saying is that for him, stating a belief in God is hypocritical unless he can actually fully walk the walk of what a truly d…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months agoI’m not going to dismiss him, because I don’t understand him. He might be Deepak Chopra by now, he might not.
-
Reg the Fronkey Farmer replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months agoI was asked recently why I have no interest in reading anything else that JP writes, especially his new book about Catholic Jesus (roughly speaking!!). I replied that he may have had some opinions worth consideration in the past but not since he was ‘Deephacked Choprafied’.
-
Unseen replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months ago_Robert_ wrote:
Oh, damn, too lateJP has become a parody of himself.
I’m reminded of a quote Google can’t find so I’ll have to paraphrase it, but JP reminds me of it:
“There’s no difference between the avant-garde and a parody of the avant-garde.”
A parody of Jordan Peterson is indistinguishable from Jordan Peterson.
-
_Robert_ replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months agojakelafort wrote:
Simon, if i want a good story i’ll read Washington Irving. Ronald Reagan might have appreciated him. Tell me a story so i know what you mean. That was me channeling the dead guy. His son is an atheist so the apple defied gravity. Somebody asks you do you believe? Have the integrity to say yes or no. And if asked for an e… -
jakelafort replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months agoSimon, if i want a good story i’ll read Washington Irving.
Ronald Reagan might have appreciated him. Tell me a story so i know what you mean. That was me channeling the dead guy. His son is an atheist so the apple defied gravity.
Somebody asks you do you believe? Have the integrity to say yes or no. And if asked for an explanation don’t go all…[Read more]
-
Unseen replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months agoUnseen wrote:
You talk about free will in a way that presupposes its existence. That’s what I accused you of in my prior post.Maybe, but my point is, that there’s evidence for its existence. If I had no free will, I could not respond to contingent, random circumstances by deliberating and picking and choosing.
Is this “ev…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months agoYes, but he deals in stories, human psychology and human nature. It doesn’t have to make perfect logical sense. It can have a psychological logic – a human logic rather than a mathematical or physical logic.
If you’re expecting a meticulously logical philosophical treatise, you won’t get one out of him. But his stories make sense in a human setting.
-
jakelafort replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months agoI think we discussed J P.
Only credit i can give him is in his treatment of some woke nonsense.
First time i listened to him debate Sam Harris i wanted to pull out my hair even if i am bald. Annoying in his intransigence and i am pretty sure Harris had his BP elevated having to debate him. And the way he arrived at his religious convictions is…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months agoUnseen wrote:
You talk about free will in a way that presupposes its existence. That’s what I accused you of in my prior post.Maybe, but my point is, that there’s evidence for its existence. If I had no free will, I could not respond to contingent, random circumstances by deliberating and picking and choosing.
Just because I can’t directly fi…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months ago_Robert_ wrote:
JP strikes me mostly as someone mostly trying to extend his 15 minutes of fame. To me he’s the “Hawk-Tua girl” of the identity wars.I don’t think he’s a fame-whore at all. Being a little bit up close to him, I was impressed with his integrity and responsibility. He was quite happy to apologise and say he was wrong about somethi…[Read more]
-
Unseen replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months agoSimon Paynton wrote:
Everything obeys rules, but that doesn’t in itself imply complete determinism. My free will is constrained by rules: I will never be able to do exactly what I like. As for the rest, I can employ free choice.You talk about free will in a way that presupposes its existence. That’s what I accused you of in my prior pos…[Read more]
-
_Robert_ replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months agoBelle Rose wrote:
@robert I wouldn’t classify JP as an atheist. I didn’t see the Sam Harris one I’ll have to watch that. I guess I view him completely differently because i watched his lectures so I understand the framework from where he’s coming and there are many things I took away from his lectures that I still use and remember to this day. I… -
Belle Rose replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months ago@Robert I wouldn’t classify JP as an atheist. I didn’t see the Sam Harris one I’ll have to watch that. I guess I view him completely differently because i watched his lectures so I understand the framework from where he’s coming and there are many things I took away from his lectures that I still use and remember to this day. I think he gets it…[Read more]
-
_Robert_ replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months agoJP strikes me mostly as someone mostly trying to extend his 15 minutes of fame. To me he’s the “Hawk-Tua girl” of the identity wars.
He has no real answers for young men because that would alienate them away from him and his fame. So instead, it’s babble-talk-time when someone like Sam Harris calls him out. I don’t see why he climbed out of bed,…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months ago_Robert_ wrote:
So, is he against egalitarianism, or just the overshoot?He’s definitely against the overshoot. I don’t pin him as anti-egalitarian. I was following him from the early days of the trans-pronoun crisis in Canada, when I was in the middle of a breakdown. Those opponents being “pummeled”? That was mainly me. I thought they were…[Read more]
-
_Robert_ replied to the topic Sunday School November 24th 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 1 year, 11 months agoJP has a problem. His fan base are mostly disillusioned young males lost in the wake of female independence. So, they revert to the good old Christian days and ways. When even the least desirable young males could attract female attention. Trouble is, JP is an atheist. So, when he talks about god and the virtues of religion, it’s just a word salad…[Read more]
- Load More