Kuba Adamów
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School 9th January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agojakelafort wrote:
As to ASPD i was under the impression it is synonymous with psychopathology.The two terms seem to be very ill-defined in the literature. According to my experience, psychopathy pretty much means a lack of emotion, especially negative emotion, and including moral emotion; and impulsivity. All the recognised cluster-B p…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 10 months agoNo, we analyze such situations in terms of the intent, not their success or failure, when it comes to an ethical analysis.
Indeed. It is absurd to base a moral judgement on chance. If a surgery is successful 90% of the time, then is it the case that in 9 operations the doctor made the right decision to operate and the 1 time the patient didn’t…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 10 months agoIntentions could be said to be putting the conditions in place for actions
Let me remove your weasel words:
Intentions are putting conditions in place for actions.
I am completely stumped on what this means. Could you please clarify Simon?
-
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 10 months agoIf you are talking about consequences then you do not seem to understand deontological ethics. In any case, you didn’t answer my question, you just answered with a statement that is really a question (“but surely”). Even if consequences were relevant (which they aren’t regarding deontological ethics), saying actions are as important as…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 10 months agoUnseen wrote:
Ethics, considered qua ethics, should be about intentions, not actions or consequences.Intentions could be said to be putting the conditions in place for actions, so under that reasoning, they’re vitally important. The hypothesis is that bad intentions lead to bad actions and bad consequences.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 10 months agoDavis wrote:
It is very difficult to imagine how one could possibly create a coherent let alone effective moral system by combining the two.But surely, both actions and consequences are important. Consequences are what we have to live with, and actions are putting the conditions in place for consequences.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School 9th January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agojakelafort wrote:
Borderline personality disorder, schizophrenia, PTSD, and a host of psychology labels are in the simplest terms, most convenient definitions.Most of these things seem to be spectrums. People with BPD are sometimes comorbid with narcissism and/or antisocial personality disorder (exploits others materially). I knew someone w…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 10 months agoUtilitarianism and deontological ethics cannot be bridged or merged or compromised. They are two totally different systems. Taking away the absolutism of deontological ethics would make it an entirely new system, as with taking away the flexibility of utilitarianism. It would not be utilitarianism anymore, but something new. It is very difficult…[Read more]
-
D joined the group
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 10 months ago -
Simon Paynton started the topic What matters – actions or consequences? in the forum
The Atheist Agora 4 years, 10 months agoIn this article, it says
Ethics is best explained via its various competing ethical theories. Utilitarianism, a moral theory defended by Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill, urges us to place moral importance on the consequences of our actions. On this view, if the consequences of an action would bring about more happiness, then the action is m…
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School 9th January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoAutumn wrote:
That just contributes to the stigmatization of autism.Some people think that autism has been adaptive in human prehistory, helping the species to innovate new technology etc.
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School 9th January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoYes, I agree (In general I find it difficult to disagree with anything you have written over the years and I do like to argue with people :-))
Indeed we are very lucky to have you here Autumn
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School 9th January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoI know. I was too brief for my own good. My point is, should someone be condemned or dismissed for having a psychological disorder?
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School 9th January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoI was referring to gender dysphoria.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School 9th January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoUnseen wrote:
dismiss people who think they aren’t absolutely 100% male or female as mentally ill?Is it dismissing someone to say that they have a psychological disorder, or is it describing them? It depends how you see it.
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School 9th January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoIs it dismissing someone, or describing them? It depends how you see it.
Simon, if you want to walk down the road of relativism then do so at your own peril.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School 9th January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoUnseen wrote:
is it a way for intelligent people who know how to use big words to dismiss people who think they aren’t absolutely 100% male or female as mentally ill?Is it dismissing someone, or describing them? It depends how you see it.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School 9th January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoDavis wrote:
I still immensely enjoy their work and don’t for a second support the idea of throwing away their additions to wordily insight, creativity and artistic enjoyment.I’m a big fan of Throbbing Gristle and Psychic TV (“industrial” music from the ’80s) but it turned out that the lead singer, Genesis P-Orridge, was a narcissistic monster a…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School 9th January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoThe link here makes sense. He’s notable within atheist circles for a reason. I don’t assume links signal an endorsement or categorical agreement with the linked content.
This is well said. Reg, you don’t have to worry so much about how we will react when you post someone who is ambiguous on the social justice scale (or all over the place or bi-…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School 9th January 2022 in the forum
Sunday School 4 years, 10 months agoSurely sex is binary but gender is a continuum or spectrum.
I have respect for Richard Dawkins but I find some of his pronouncements crass and ignorant and embarrassing.
- Load More