Kara Connor
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
It may well be that @kingiyk‘s “proof” is logically consistent, i.e., logically valid. When AI checks it, it validates it on the grounds of internal logical consistency.
But that’s not the same as being empirically valid – valid in the real world. To be valid in the real world, all the premises have to be real (I don’t know – I assume) and t…[Read more]
-
Reg the Fronkey Farmer replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
It is patently clear you are incapable of reasoned debate. I am only replying for the sake of others that might be reading this from the sidelines.
“AI attested to it” is not a meaningful claim. LLMs are not intelligent systems. Just ask one if it is. They echo coherence, not correctness. If AI affirmations counted as validation, then nume…[Read more]
-
Reg the Fronkey Farmer replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
You said in the parting gift of your last paragraph that “The Bible’s God is Triune, demonstrated not assumed”.
But demonstrated how? All you have done is to show that patterns can be extracted from a text and that symbolic triad can be (re)arranged, Nothing is demonstrated.
“When treated as data rather than prose”….once again, this is a catego…[Read more]
-
Reg the Fronkey Farmer replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
There is so much wrong here that I am not sure where to start. I will pick some points out. The whole piece reminds me of what Dan Dennett called a ‘deepity’. Lots of big words too so I will try not to be too much of a sesquipedalian.
‘But conceptual analysis still carries a burden: a concept that does not exist in its source domain cannot gen…[Read more]
-
Reg the Fronkey Farmer replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
If I was on that flight I would start singing “Allahu Akbar” and if asked to stop,would then sue the airline for religious discrimination.
-
Reg the Fronkey Farmer replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
@Simon – I am not trying to prove it false. I am evaluating whether it is textually grounded and conceptually coherent. I was doing conceptual analysis, not arguing metaphysics. The doctrine of the Trinity is not derivable from the text it claims as its source. My claim stands, irrespective of the existence or not of the Christian God. I’m not c…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
Reg the Fronkey Farmer wrote:
The Trinity presupposes a God-concept that the Bible itself never articulates.But that doesn’t prove the Trinity is wrong.
Can we atheists recognise the wrongness of a description of something we think doesn’t exist? Not even wrong?
-
Reg the Fronkey Farmer replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
The Trinity presupposes a God-concept that the Bible itself never articulates. The God presented in the Bible is a single personal agent, whereas the Trinity redefines God as a “tri-personal” being which is a category shift not made by the biblical authors.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
Simon Paynton wrote:
An AI proof isn’t proof.Unless it’s a dedicated theorem prover, or an AI program which has specifically been asked to prove a theorem, without flattering the user.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
TheEncogitationer wrote:
It puts out affirmation for every bit of nonsenseI think that AI flatters people.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School December 14th 2025 in the forum
Sunday School 11 months agoTheEncogitationer wrote:
I’m saying there was no Garden of Eden or “Golden Age” or “Noble Savagery”, whether terrifying, beautiful, or otherwise.No power, no oppression, no money, no patriarchy? Sounds great. It’s true that people died very young though.
-
Reg the Fronkey Farmer replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
@Simon – “They don’t share their entire beings, yet they share their God-nature.”
This is not Nicene Trinitarianism. The orthodoxy explicitly says that ‘Each person is fully God”. Not partially god, not a piece of God and certainly not overlapping subsets. When you say “The Venn diagram doesn’t fully overlap” you are asserting partial identit…[Read more]
-
Reg the Fronkey Farmer replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
I wonder what Arius who make of this version of Who by Fire (Leonard Cohen). I think Arius would be allergic to metaphysical inflation and ask Christians to stop smuggling mystery in where clarity will do. He would say that there is one ultimate source (God the Father). Creation runs largely on order, consequence, and necessity and there is no…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
Reg the Fronkey Farmer wrote:
If Father = fully GodAnd Son = fully God
And Father ≠ Son
Then “God” is both identical and non-identical.
You now have:
God = Father
God = Son
Father ≠ Son
This violates the basic identity logic: If A = C and B = C, then A = B.
You can’t escape bad logic with theological wordplay.
I’m not sure I agree that your refu…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
King Iyk wrote:
explain how a precise, formal model of it could be extracted from the immutable fabrics of reality: immaterial time and immaterial mathematics, converging at the crucifixion?Coincidental synthetic patterns. We can join the dots however we like.
King Iyk wrote:
explain why the foremost advancement of the human race in the… -
Reg the Fronkey Farmer replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
Why do you reject what the Bible says about God and His son Jesus?
-
Reg the Fronkey Farmer replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
@King Iyk – I reject Trinitarianism, not because I am an atheist but because I have studied the Bible. The word “Trinity” does not appear anywhere in the Bible. The fully formed doctrine of ‘one God in three co-equal, co-eternal persons’ as described to me in Catholic school, is not explicitly stated in either the Old or New Testamen…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
@Robert – you’re assuming that the Bible is proposed as proof of God’s existence, when that may be too much burden. Maybe the Bible is not supposed to make sense, but God does.
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
The thing is, it’s impossible to prove or disprove the existence of God, by logic or any other means, in this world we have. Evidence would be nice; failing that, it’s unprovable either way.
-
Reg the Fronkey Farmer replied to the topic A Formal Mathematical Model of The Holy Trinity. in the forum Atheism 11 months ago
I am going to called this “Rube Goldberg” theology. Finding a pattern after the fact doesn’t explain anything. Your post-hoc pattern mining can make any number appear special if you look long enough.
- Load More