jakelafort

  • jakelafort started the topic UNTESTED in the forum Politics 8 years, 3 months ago

    To practice law, medicine, a host of other professions and even hair cutting the candidate must prove their competence by taking an exam and passing.  Yet political office has no such requirement. Where is the sense in allowing Trumps of the world to gain access to the most significant position in the USA and be utterly unqualified?

    A more…[Read more]

  • Belen, there is nothing outrageous about your prediction.  In fact if we only extrapolate the past we see how likely it is.  Man has weapon.  Man uses weapon.  Wars have increased in scale.  The 3o years war of the 17th century is sometimes viewed as the first world war although it was missing many parties. But now the world has gotten so much…[Read more]

  • Ok Simon, astute, which is ta say yaar playing some goddamn ball!

  • Manners is too effete a characterization.  I guess control or decency.

  • Chimps, our close relatives are in need of some manners also.  Males drag females away from troop and rape.  So it is innate, cultural or a combination?

  • jakelafort replied to the topic Religious Parents in the forum Advice 8 years, 3 months ago

    Emma, in making a decision you gotta balance the benefit of  disclosure against the potential repercussions.

    You can live your life without telling her.  I don’t see it as diminishing your integrity if you decide to keep it close to the vest.

    If telling her will take a weight off of your conscience and give you a big boost and you can tolerate t…[Read more]

  • jakelafort posted a new activity comment 8 years, 4 months ago

    Thank you Davis for the many references. If i get sufficiently curious and ambitious i shall procure one of those. Lately i just go to library and buy used books cheap cheap.

  • jakelafort posted a new activity comment 8 years, 4 months ago

    So Davis you misunderstand me. I am not calling philosophers who work on issues related to free will theists. It is not an analogy i am drawing. (It is a dynamic. )Instead i am questioning whether their objectivity is compromised because of their discomfort in a life without any vestige of free will. Theists who have an intellectual bent are not…[Read more]

    • By the way, I should point out that two other members here have read through Freedom Evolves, our resident Fronkey Farmer and Simon Matthews (I wish he was still around). He offered a nice summary of the book on Thinkatheist, though you’ll forgive me if I don’t root through 800 comments of his on the old site to find it.

    • Thank you Davis for the many references. If i get sufficiently curious and ambitious i shall procure one of those. Lately i just go to library and buy used books cheap cheap.

  • jakelafort posted a new activity comment 8 years, 4 months ago

    Your account of the development of the issue(s) reminds me of how theists rationalize. The Earles, Doctor Bobs, Jordan Petersons are conflicted. On one hand they are repelled by the absence of reason in support of their darling, on other they emotionally need their belief. So they rationalize to reconcile the conflict.

    Without their personal…[Read more]

    • Well Jake, first of all, its all theorhetic and no one is making any strong claims. Christians do. SEcondly, none of these people are making supernatural claims but trying to understand how individual choice is meaningful in a clockwork universe…which isn’t even remotely like Christians arguing out of negatives and arguments from ignorance nor…[Read more]

      • Or one can stand on a Soap box and keep proclaiming that the sun doesn’t revolve around the Earth and when people conceded this and ask if the Earth can be centric in any sense, well, stick your fingers in your ears and go…[Read more]

        • Meanwhile the Moon keeps going around the Earth as well as all sorts of Satellites and space junk.

        • So Davis you misunderstand me. I am not calling philosophers who work on issues related to free will theists. It is not an analogy i am drawing. (It is a dynamic. )Instead i am questioning whether their objectivity is compromised because of their discomfort in a life without any vestige of free will. Theists who have an intellectual bent are not…[Read more]

          • By the way, I should point out that two other members here have read through Freedom Evolves, our resident Fronkey Farmer and Simon Matthews (I wish he was still around). He offered a nice summary of the book on Thinkatheist, though you’ll forgive me if I don’t root through 800 comments of his on the old site to find it.

          • Thank you Davis for the many references. If i get sufficiently curious and ambitious i shall procure one of those. Lately i just go to library and buy used books cheap cheap.

  • Mr. Bean I am not sure you have been familiarized with the notion of super intelligence. Just a guess.

    If you have not please search general intelligence, super intelligence and AI. I would give you a link but i am sans mouse.

  • jakelafort posted a new activity comment 8 years, 4 months ago

    Somehow you have organized this parley!

  • So Mr. Bean, if and when AI supersedes its design, its intended purpose by becoming autonomous, self aware and independent and ultimately produces super intelligence we will be to AI as a bug is to us.

    I know people try to make educated guesses as to how things will play out. Will AI be malevolent, neutral or beneficial? I have not the…[Read more]

    • Here’s an irony, I believe. AI will supercede us due to geeks with big egos designing it. And AI may just destroy us because of one issue I rarely hear mentioned: What AI does will be largely determined by whichever human actors OWN the AI.

  • Not only do i deny free will exists in carbon based actors I question how it is possible on a theoretical basis. And if AI achieves free will then i wonder whether it is supernatural.

    Yes, our thoughts, behavior, mood is externally caused. Our microbiome plays a part, our dopamine and seratonin, the drugs we take, the coffee we drink, the food…[Read more]

  • No, Mr. Bean, the issue with groups and joining is idiosyncratic. I am a weirdo.
    Did not mean to besmirch, belittle or cover in spittle…
    I will withdraw unless there is further commentary.

    • No, please don’t withdraw, but I was planning my own withdraw after giving adequate responsiveness to your activity. (It was also a test on my part to see what work it would entail. Not as bad as I thought.)

  • What the hammer?
    What the chain?
    In what furnace was Tom’s brain?

  • Sorry Mr. Bean, but i have some hang-up about joining groups. Rough enough to be a member on this site.

    Yes, i think self-awareness is on a scale or spectrum. In humans a person in a coma, minimally conscious state or in latter stages of alzheimers on one end and a meditating yogi Prabhupada Baktivedanti his divine grace on other. Regular and…[Read more]

    • You said: “Sorry Mr. Bean, but i have some hang-up about joining groups. Rough enough to be a member on this site.”
      I say: I accidentally just found this update you posted, because it’s not in the “usual” kind of place to maintain a thread, unless one checks every member’s page of of their personal updates. Are you saying a group is “rough”…[Read more]

    • … and this page lacks an editing feature, so I can’t fix the myriad of typos and poor writer syndrome I’m afflicted with. Anyway…
      You said: “You may not like to discuss other animals […]”
      I say: That was just a suggestion wrt that single “Starters” post, for the sake of simplicity because I think it’s much easier to *start* sharing human…[Read more]

    • You said: “or perhaps we rationalize by elevating the cerebral cortex”
      I say: True, which is absolutely relevant when compared to amoebas (sp?), but only relatively relevant wrt other animals that also have cerebral cortices, only smaller.

    • You said: ” An individual can only have free will if in full control of faculties, thoughts and behavior. Such an individual can do as she will and will as she will.”
      I say: I understand that, but think it oversimplifies a potentially deep aspect of free will, e.g. what about people who are mentally disabled, especially those that have lost some…[Read more]

      • And I forgot or neglected to mention, what do you mean by “full control of faculties”? I don’t know about you, but I cannot even know when I’m in full control from day to day, much less *ever*. That strongly hints to me the sliding scale of capability, which in the bigger picture even hints to me a difference in capability (and therefor access to…[Read more]

    • You said: “It seems to me human conceit to assume consciousness and awareness is exclusively the domain of the biological critters. And seeing how far and fast AI has progressed makes sense to me it will be aware and the extrapolation of the experts in seeing the genesis of super intelligence is idk…a good wager?”
      I say: OK, but the advancement o…[Read more]

  • Yes to hammers without nails. See hammerhead shark.

  • Well Bean Man, used to have a pothead friend in college with that nickname, wonder is a result of self-awareness. Don’t think wonder can emerge without self-awareness. So is that your answer as to the signaling of free will? Cuz in and of itself i don’t see how it has any bearing on the numerous objections to free will. Furthermore AI will become…[Read more]

    • I think self-awareness is on a spectrum, along with free will, wonder, and other aspects of consciousness. When I’m looking awestruck at stars in the sky, I don’t feel self-aware, other than feeling like I’m just part of a bigger picture. Now, a statement like
      “AI will become self-aware” needs more definitions, evidence, or explanations behind it…[Read more]

  • How could free will exist? Even as a construct?

    If we have it do other animals as well? What event signal the emergence of free will in us and other animals?

    Is free will a possibility in AI since it will not have undergone the prison and chains of biology?

    • The construct or *concept* of Free Will may only exist in biological entities that *wonder* about it. An other non-wondering, or artificially created entity might never have Free Will. What if Free Will is a slippery beast merely only when it can define *itself*?

  • Unfearl the Earle.

    Each prophecy a pearl.

    Tell us more.  Tell us more.  You’ve uncovered it.  We adore.

  • Load More