jakelafort

  • jakelafort replied to the topic The Power of Prayer in the forum Atheism 9 years, 1 month ago

    I also think they help bring out apostasy in some people who hear and read em.  In my experience former theists are mostly relieved to leave religion in rear view mirror.  Your experience was different.  I am willing to bet it is mostly a liberating experience which is weird to conceive since the realization of no god comes with the acceptance of…[Read more]

  • jakelafort replied to the topic The Power of Prayer in the forum Atheism 9 years, 1 month ago

    Man you are angry!

    It is not fair to say they never had a struggle.  Take Bertrand Russell.  He grew up in a well to do family but had plenty of angst. Hitchens got cancer. Life aint easy.  Does anybody get out of this mess unscathed?

    But in fairness t0 you i think there is a tendency of super smart people to be a little arrogant.  But ath…[Read more]

  • jakelafort replied to the topic The Power of Prayer in the forum Atheism 9 years, 1 month ago

    Ok, Belle i hearya. It is tone you don’t like.

  • jakelafort replied to the topic The Power of Prayer in the forum Atheism 9 years, 1 month ago

    Belle, you have spoken ill of Hitchens and perhaps some other atheist thinkers. I am wondering whether you can give a passage and critique it.

    I am bored reading atheist literature but have rarely found flaws in the reasoning of the big names.  You have anything specific you would like to point out?

  • jakelafort replied to the topic The Power of Prayer in the forum Atheism 9 years, 1 month ago

    Belle, it says i cant answer.

  • jakelafort replied to the topic The Power of Prayer in the forum Atheism 9 years, 1 month ago

    Belle, once again, it is misleading to conceive of hominids having evolved to believe in gods.  Our biology makes SOME of us vulnerable to believing in gods. Not all of us.  Our propensity for belief is a function of our upbringing,  and our intelligence.  Keep in mind also that not all people in all places have belief in gods.  There are othe…[Read more]

  • jakelafort replied to the topic The Power of Prayer in the forum Atheism 9 years, 1 month ago

    Belle, I am not kidding.

    How is it relevant?

    Getting a good job is good for mental health.  Discovering that a person loves you when you had thought you were unimportant to them is good for mental health.  Taking the right medication can be good for mental health. Getting sufficient sleep likewise good for mental health.

    So?

  • jakelafort replied to the topic The Power of Prayer in the forum Atheism 9 years, 1 month ago

    Belle, i am not resisting. It can be good for mental health. So can a lot of practices like meditation and community. Feeling like we belong and that people care about us is important.

    But it is not relevant to the question of god’s existence..

  • jakelafort replied to the topic The Power of Prayer in the forum Atheism 9 years, 1 month ago

    Belle, we also evolved to believe in gremlins, leprechauns, witches, tooth fairies, bigfoot, ghosts, and the list goes on and on.  Then again Hitler and Mussolini, emperors thought to be divine and various cult leaders are believed to be authentic and the masses alter their behavior in accordance with their beliefs. My point is that we did not…[Read more]

  • jakelafort replied to the topic The Power of Prayer in the forum Atheism 9 years, 1 month ago

    It may be slightly misleading to say we have evolved to believe in gods.

    Our evolution has made man susceptible to belief. But belief is more widespread or encompassing than gods. There are other superstitious beliefs, cultural myths and idiosyncratic beliefs.

    This state of affairs making us susceptible to belief is likely a result of our being…[Read more]

  • jakelafort replied to the topic The Power of Prayer in the forum Atheism 9 years, 1 month ago

    Robert I know atheists in India.

    Atheists in nations consumed by religious nonsense tend to be way smarter than average.

     

     

     

     

     

    a

  • It certainly doesn’t benefit me, or anyone here.

    Your words Dang.

  • jakelafort replied to the topic The Power of Prayer in the forum Atheism 9 years, 2 months ago

    Dang, dang, you are kinda mean, gratuituously so…

    Does it occur to you that Belle is bonded with people here and in turn others may be bonded with her? You speak for all of the members in saying she does not benefit anyone here?

    All you do is pick with fights and declare yourself a victim? That is hyperbole.

    Why be mean? What do you get out…[Read more]

  • Belle, the woods are lovely dark and deep and rural Guatemala is a fine place to sleep.

    In other news I agree with you.

  • You know what is interesting Belle?

    I have run into so many hikers on the Appalachian Trail who are happy. I am talking about through hikers who have committed six months to complete the trail.  These through hikers have foregone all of the conveniences of modernity.  After burning a gazillion calories and going hard for eight hours on the t…[Read more]

  • Belle, my guess is that mental illness is less prevalent among such people.  But i doubt it is absent since it seems to be part of  nature for mammals.  It would be a great area for anthropology to examine …head into the amazon and make friends with some one of those isolated tribes..

    It might shed light on the price of modernity.

  • i wonder whether indigenous people are less subject to mental illness.

  • Seems like issue of whether anything is truly random is reformulation of determinism.  If effect follows cause in an unbroken chain then nothing is random. But what of a “beginning”? Perhaps that is random.  The failure to grasp the nature of reality has no apparent bearing on issue of random or determined. (intentionally avoiding quantum p…[Read more]

  • Load More