physeter
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoUnseen wrote:
If nature gives people the wrong genitalia (or if they so believe), clearly something is wrong either in the genes or in the mind.I think it goes deeper than belief. Belief is just the surface manifestation. At the moment, if something is “wrong”, it’s fixed by people psychologically identifying with/biologically changing to t…[Read more]
-
Unseen replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoStrega wrote:
Strong movement? Is that like big strong men coming up to you crying because they feel their LGB status has been etymologically distorted by the T outlier? Oh come on.An insinuendo of transphobia does not a valid argument make.
If nature gives people the wrong genitalia (or if they so believe), clearly something is wrong either in…[Read more]
-
Autumn replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoStrega wrote:
Strong movement? Is that like big strong men coming up to you crying because they feel their LGB status has been etymologically distorted by the T outlier? Oh come on.That and the old “they’re trying to convert our children” chestnut pedalling the notion that doctors are trying to convert gay people to straight through medical…[Read more]
-
Strega replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoStrong movement? Is that like big strong men coming up to you crying because they feel their LGB status has been etymologically distorted by the T outlier?
Oh come on.
-
Unseen replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoSimon Paynton wrote:
I believe it’s like being gay. People are born that way. Do you believe that being gay is all psychological, and therefore (presumably) false?I don’t doubt that people are born gay but do you know why this happens? Anyway, there’s no problem regarding gays that needs an explanation.
As for trans people, I’m sure some peo…[Read more]
-
Strega replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoCouldn’t find Claire’s but this one’s Franklins response to
“Why is it when discussing gender and sexes that biologically there are only a possibility of x and y gametes determining either sex male and female, but gender is being considered not biological?”
The idea that there is biologically only the possibility of X and Y making ma…[Read more]
-
Unseen replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoBTW, don’t misread me as saying all gender reassignments are due to misdiagnosis. If I were to say, for example, “There has been a suspicious surge in caesarean sections in the last 20 years,” that isn’t a blanket condemnation of the procedure but is rather a statement that such a surge should have an explanation.
-
Strega replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoHi Unseen, I think I believed that when I first considered trans people. I thought it was partly psychological.
I discovered some amazing information from biologists and genetics people over on another kind of forum. So I’m going to head back there and see if I can find just one good explanation – there’s a biologist called Claire Jordan who I’m…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoUnseen wrote:
I simply find it hard to believe that this belief that one’s genitalia are lying to you is not based in psychology rather than genetics.If Nature is dishing out the wrong genitalia, I’d like to know how that could possibly happen and isn’t it really more likely something going on in the subject’s mind?
I believe it’s like being g…[Read more]
-
Unseen replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoSimon Paynton wrote:
I know someone who’s just come out as trans. It’s a genuine thing. He is much happier now identifying as male than being a she.I’m happy for him. Really. I hope anyone who goes through “the change” is happier for it, just like someone who feels they need a facial tattoo or to wear the other gender’s clothing.
I simply fin…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoI know someone who’s just come out as trans. It’s a genuine thing. He is much happier now identifying as male than being a she.
-
Autumn replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoStrega wrote:
Hi Autumn :). I’m learning. I really appreciate your ability to capture these issues in writing so clearly. Please don’t forget what you told me once, many years ago. For all the visible readers and posters, there’s a multiplication of people we reach who read without commenting. xxxI appreciate the reminder, sincerely.
-
Autumn replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoTo find that highly ponderable isn’t hate or an attack on human rights.
I think you have a point. Some people apparently say it is.
Except that’s not what people are saying. The concern is a transphobic trope of a ‘contagion’ effect which uses the increase in openly trans people and youth seeking gender-affirming care to i…[Read more]
-
Autumn replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoAutumn wrote:
’cause if we’re talking any other facet of fairness in women’s sports then the only people who give a shit are female athletes and a subset of feminists, I suppose.But I think this situation represents a genuine dilemma, since fairness to one side means potential unfairness to another.
There is no fairn…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoAutumn wrote:
’cause if we’re talking any other facet of fairness in women’s sports then the only people who give a shit are female athletes and a subset of feminists, I suppose.Most people care about fairness and justice, for themselves and others, which is why there are non-trans trans activists. But I think this situation represents a genuin…[Read more]
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoUnseen wrote:
So, thinking out loud that it’s very very strange that seemingly all of a sudden people—especially children—are discovering that Nature gave them the wrong genitals is a way of suppressing people’s rights?Some people may think it’s strange, and what that means is that some people think it’s strange, like a lot of things.
I believe…[Read more]
-
Unseen replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoSimon Paynton wrote:
I can see your point: one side is fighting for their own rights; the other is fighting to prevent them having rights.So, thinking out loud that it’s very very strange that seemingly all of a sudden people—especially children—are discovering that Nature gave them the wrong genitals is a way of suppressing people’s rights? To…[Read more]
-
jakelafort replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoTry as you may it is pointless and sophomoric to educate me on horse racing, Robert on music or Enco on Looney Tunes!
-
Simon Paynton replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoAutumn wrote:
were you merely thinking aloudThat, and aiming for you to say stuff about it.
-
Strega replied to the topic Sunday School July 30th 2023. in the forum
Sunday School 3 years, 3 months agoHi Autumn :). I’m learning. I really appreciate your ability to capture these issues in writing so clearly. Please don’t forget what you told me once, many years ago.
For all the visible readers and posters, there’s a multiplication of people we reach who read without commenting.
xxx
- Load More