Seth Rosen
@sethirosen
Active 6 years, 1 month ago-
Davis replied to the topic The outing game in the forum
To Do or not To Do 11 years, 4 months agoI understand what he is trying to say. You cannot choose to be gay but you can choose to be a homophobic-homosexual. You can choose to be an activist against racism but you can also choose to be a secretly-racist activist against racism. The first part in each phrase doesn’t matter…it’s the latter part that does. The difference (per the first…[Read more]
-
Strega posted an update in the group
Atheist Zone 11 years, 4 months agoPlease note that updated Guidelines are now available for you to review. There is a menu item “Guidelines” which holds this information, and the Moderators do urge you to review these at your earliest opportunity. Thanks, everyone!
-
Strega replied to the topic The outing game in the forum
To Do or not To Do 11 years, 4 months ago@Davis. Re your huh?, I was also busy huffing, but I had another read of Unseens comments and I realize he is simply pointing out that racism and being gay aren’t comparable in that we believe we are born with our sexual orientation, whereas we learn racism.
-
Strega replied to the topic That was a bit rude of me not to introduce myself first… in the forum Introductions 11 years, 4 months ago
Hey Kuba, delighted to have you on board!
-
Davis replied to the topic The outing game in the forum
To Do or not To Do 11 years, 4 months agoAny attack based on hypocricy is ipso facto an ad hominem tu quoque. In other words, “You say one thing but do the opposite.”
No…this falacy applies to debate on a particular topic (which is not under debate here). It does not apply when considering the weight of someone’s opinion in a decision making process, as a leader or as a rep…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic The outing game in the forum
To Do or not To Do 11 years, 4 months agoJust read Davis’s reply to this, and he brought up some scenarios, completely different from outing a hypocritical bible thumper (the situation I had in mind when I wrote the above), where outing is not only appropriate but downright necessary (e.g., exposing an enemy agent of influence in your ranks).
And so…outing someone who works against y…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic The outing game in the forum
To Do or not To Do 11 years, 4 months agoIt is true that there are a portion of self-hating homosexuals who believe they don’t deserve the rights that everyone else does. The only thing is…the record of outed politicians who admit that they are gay and then move on to champion gay rights is pretty high. Randy Boehning is but the most recent example.
An ad hominem attack only…[Read more]
-
D and
kphee are now friends 11 years, 4 months ago
-
Strega replied to the topic The outing game in the forum
To Do or not To Do 11 years, 4 months agoI believe we are in a kind of grey area, where either side’s position is correct dependent on the circumstances. I’m quite sure we can both create scenarios to support the two positions.
In this situation, I’d usually fall back on the golden rule, do no harm etc…
-
Davis replied to the topic The outing game in the forum
To Do or not To Do 11 years, 4 months agoif this had been a black and white clear cut matter, you would not have raised it in a moral debate now would you?
Hence phrases like “I’m not so sure” or “that’s one way of looking at it”.
I believe there is a moral blind spot in us when we ridicule others, because I think it feeds into a smug sense of superiority by the ridiculer that is…
-
Strega replied to the topic The outing game in the forum
To Do or not To Do 11 years, 4 months agoif this had been a black and white clear cut matter, you would not have raised it in a moral debate now would you? 🙂
I believe there is a moral blind spot in us when we ridicule others, because I think it feeds into a smug sense of superiority by the ridiculer that is primitive and not particularly socially helpful.
Outing someone is an act…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School July 19th 2015 in the forum
Sunday School 11 years, 4 months agoI have created a PDF file with all of the non-video articles for easy reading on phone or tablet. I’ve made it public so anyone can download it off my google drive. Surprisingly it is only 10Mb … and most joyously … I’ve left the comments sections out!
The link is here.
-
Davis replied to the topic The outing game in the forum
To Do or not To Do 11 years, 4 months ago@Strega ,
Calling out a homosexual intent on limiting the rights of others (as well as himself) to keep his seat in a legislature…is not ad hominem. It’s revealing that the person…quite likely…doesn’t even agree with the argument he is making. How is that ad hominem? It would be ad hominem if we said “hey…that politician was a closeted…[Read more]
-
Strega replied to the topic Hello from Egypt in the forum Introductions 11 years, 4 months ago
Hi welcome to Atheist Zone – I hope you find the group you are looking for here 🙂
-
Strega replied to the topic Sunday School July 19th 2015 in the forum
Sunday School 11 years, 4 months ago_Robert_ wrote:After reading about what Ken Ham has to say, I was thinking the worse part is that we will never know that we are right and he will never know that he was wrong.
I already know, Robert! Sure as eggs is eggs 🙂
-
Strega replied to the topic Hello from SE Virginia! in the forum Introductions 11 years, 4 months ago
Welcome to AtheistZone! Atheists abound here!
-
Strega replied to the topic The outing game in the forum
To Do or not To Do 11 years, 4 months agoI think ‘outing’ is discrediting a person, not his or her opinions and actions. So you call out a hypocrite. You out a guy for having homosexual phone sex whilst voting against LGBT protections. How is that helping the cause?
First of all, you’re declaring he is secretly part of the LGBT community, thus making that community seem hypocritical…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic The outing game in the forum
To Do or not To Do 11 years, 4 months agoIndeed. Predatory banking is a silly example and hardly relates to what we are talking about here (those who campaign or vote to discriminate against a protected class of people (while they moonlight as one of them) attacking their rights, dignity, sense of equality and making them lesser than others. Outing this person is hardly…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School July 19th 2015 in the forum
Sunday School 11 years, 4 months agoOh very nice Sunday school Reg. I especially like the reincarnation woo of the week. So easy to forget about this little woo (as it so rarely comes up and is so rarely linked to agression or nasty behaviour on the part of such woo-meisters).
-
Strega joined the group
Tips 11 years, 4 months ago - Load More