tom sarbeck
@toms
Active 3 years, 11 months ago-
PopeBeanie replied to the topic An atheist can't believe in free will in the forum Small Talk 2 years, 10 months ago
Unseen wrote:
You still haven’t, despite about three requests now, given us the definition of free will or told me whether my cat has free will.For me too, that’s the elephant in the kitchen. Or maybe the bathroom. Or homunculus. (jk, see?) One of the believed-in implications is that there is a soul or other supernatural force that magically e…[Read more]
-
D replied to the topic An atheist can't believe in free will in the forum Small Talk 2 years, 10 months ago
“Influence” on how people decide to live their lives, infers “choice”. Is choice meaningful or not Pope? If it is not, then influencing someone’s choice is not meaningful either. This is not rocket science.
-
PopeBeanie replied to the topic An atheist can't believe in free will in the forum Small Talk 2 years, 10 months ago
Davis wrote:
If one argues others have no choice to have done but what they have done, have no agency, it is absurd to then, in the same book, go on to try and influence their future choices/agency.Free will or not, it’s a given that Harris’ readers can be influenced by his advice. Sapolski’s too, or anyone’s here.
I’m realizing that it doesn’t…[Read more]
-
D replied to the topic An atheist can't believe in free will in the forum Small Talk 2 years, 10 months ago
There is no superficiality about it. If one argues others have no choice to have done but what they have done, have no agency, it is absurd to then, in the same book, go on to try and influence their future choices/agency. The only way around that is magical thinking or special pleading.
If we don’t have free will, we are not responsible for our…[Read more]
-
Strega replied to the topic Sunday School 14th January 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 2 years, 10 months agoOn the book banning front, Florida’s Bill O’Reilly was horrified, after emphatically supporting Florida’s book banning activity, to discover that his own two books are also banned.
Much mockery ensued, with Jeff Tiedrich taking the prize with the following…
“Republicans sure do love to ban them some books.
but it’s all fun and games until the…[Read more]
-
Strega replied to the topic Sunday School 14th January 2024 in the forum
Sunday School 2 years, 10 months agoThanks, Reg!!!
-
D replied to the topic An atheist can't believe in free will in the forum Small Talk 2 years, 10 months ago
I remember reading Sam Harris’s atrocious book on free will. In the first half he dismisses free will. In the second half he talks about how we “should” look at the world in a different way. And then advice about how to best live your life. He still stands by it. One half of his book talks about how we have no choice but to do what we do, and then…[Read more]
-
D replied to the topic An atheist can't believe in free will in the forum Small Talk 2 years, 10 months ago
There is a common concern that without free will there’s no accountability. Nonsense. We will go on holding people to account because we have to, in the sense that this is how we respond to acts that displease or enrage us. We respond in this way because we have to. Literally. We have no real choice but respond that way.
That’s such a cop out. B…[Read more]
-
PopeBeanie replied to the topic An atheist can't believe in free will in the forum Small Talk 2 years, 10 months ago
@Unseen What difference does it make, whether or not Free Will actually exists? Recently I’m thinking that all that matters in terms of how we think and behave is whether or not we believe in it. (And yes, I’m good with saying that what we believe in is also determined… just as are the external, environmental effects on our internal state. While…[Read more]
-
PopeBeanie replied to the topic An atheist can't believe in free will in the forum Small Talk 2 years, 10 months ago
Unseen wrote:
[…] We will go on holding people to account because we have to, in the sense that this is how we respond to acts that displease or enrage us. We respond in this way because we have to. Literally. We have no real choice but respond that way.Increasingly often, I’m wondering how important it is to answer this question with…[Read more]
-
D replied to the topic An atheist can't believe in free will in the forum Small Talk 2 years, 10 months ago
Yeah, it seems like we have “agency”; but is it real? Probably not, but the best answer is that we simply don’t know yet.
Agency is as real and meaningful as: decision, responsibility, culpability, power structures, invention, reward, retribution, entitlement, ownership, merit etc. Dismiss one…you should dismiss them all. If one is meani…[Read more]
-
PopeBeanie replied to the topic Nobody saw this coming in the forum Small Talk 2 years, 10 months ago
NEWS FLASH!! Person A DESTROYS Person B. The REAL TRUTH about Blah Blah. These days, those are headlines I skip over. But when it comes to tons of new reactions to The Warning still coming out from people who haven’t heard of them, Pope Beanie finds new favorites. In this case, four guys happened to pick a great song/official video for their first…[Read more]
-
PopeBeanie replied to the topic Nobody saw this coming in the forum Small Talk 2 years, 10 months ago
I’ve liked Don Music for a while, he’s above others in the experience and reporting department. Thanks for the reminder, I’ll watch these later.
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School 7th January 2024. in the forum
Sunday School 2 years, 10 months agoYou keep using two different kinds of language as though “control” is meaningful if “choice” is meaningless.
If free will is an illusion, then control is an illusion (as is morality or consequence). That’s fine, I’m not saying with any certainty any of that exist. But it is ridiculous to dismiss meaningful choice, and still hold onto anything…[Read more]
-
Strega replied to the topic Sunday School 7th January 2024. in the forum
Sunday School 2 years, 10 months agoThanks, Reg!
-
D replied to the topic Are the lefties destroying America? A debate topic. in the forum Politics 2 years, 10 months ago
Nah not going to watch a bullshit video with a bullshit title. Civilisation is not being destroyed. At worst, some things we consider important are being chipped away at. We are far from “destroyed”. The very language of the title of this video screams “watching this will rot your brain”.
The left nor the right is not destroying anything. A lack…[Read more]
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School 31st December 2023 in the forum
Sunday School 2 years, 10 months agoI wouldn’t exactly characterise, as a whole, the hundreds of millions of atheists in China, as free thinkers. Atheism does not equal Western, Educated, Sceptical, Freethinking Humanism.
-
PopeBeanie replied to the topic Music Origins, History, Creation, Special Musicians… in the forum Small Talk 2 years, 10 months ago
(Relatively) new eyes on classic rock. This reactor says she was an actor, once. I think she enjoys putting people on, reminding me a bit of Philomena Cunk. (She is smarter than she acts.)
-
Strega replied to the topic Sunday School 31st December 2023 in the forum
Sunday School 2 years, 10 months agoThanks, Reg!
Happy New Year!!!
-
Davis replied to the topic Sunday School 24th December 2023 in the forum
Sunday School 2 years, 10 months agoWe encounter scenarios like the prisoners dilemma more often than you think. And these test your integrity to your values when under pressure. At work two of us were at fault with a client, if we admit the error the client had a very tiny chance of being badly affected but guaranteed to complain and create problems for everyone and harm the…[Read more]
- Load More